Tug-Of-War: How To Find the Right Tug Toy For Your Dog

It doesn’t have to be a battle.

September 22, 2022

Your pet wants you to read our newsletter. (Then give them a treat.)

As kids, we learned that playing tug is pretty much a bad idea. One team is always stronger than the other, and someone ends up crying at the school nurse’s office with a bag of ice strapped to their arm. If you’re a dog, though, the rules are different.

Tug is a great game for most dogs, and they can learn a lot from playing it. Many trainers share this view and actually teach tug in puppy classes. The earlier dogs learn the lessons that tug has to offer — such as impulse control, mouth control, and cooperation, as well as skills, such as “take it” and “drop it” — the safer and more fun the game becomes.

For a long time, experts advised against playing tug with dogs for fear that it would create or increase aggressiveness in dogs. Later, tug was considered fine for most dogs, as long as they were not allowed to “win” by keeping the toy at the end. The current thinking is that dogs, like people, understand it’s just a game.

For most dogs, tug has many benefits, as long as you check with your behaviorist and veterinarian first that it is an appropriate and safe activity. It is interactive and requires cooperation between humans and dogs. It can give dogs exercise and help them stretch their bodies prior to other activities, such as running or agility training.

Here are eight rope toys that will excite any tug-obsessed pup.

Wild One Triangle Tug

$16

Keeping your puppy entertained is no walk in the park (except when it literally is). When they lose their interest in interactive toys (probable) or finish chewing through your last set of shoe laces (inevitable), you’re going to need a backup. In comes Wild One’s Triangle Tug toy, which engages your pup’s chomping instincts in a healthy way. It’s made of natural rubber with a reinforced core, so it won’t be destroyed within minutes of use. Plus, it’s pretty.

$16 at Wild One

SodaPup Can Pull Tab

$19

This interactive toy is non-toxic, made of rubber, and durable enough to withstand the force of your pup’s fangs. The pull tab handle makes for easy playtime with your dog and will engage them in some serious exercise while strengthening your bond. Who wouldn’t want to sit on the floor for half an hour spending with their pup? You might even get an upper body workout out of it.

$19 at Amazon

West Paw Zogoflex Bumi Dog Tug Toy

$20

Just because your pup is teacup sized doesn’t mean they don’t need something to sink their teeth into. Made for gentle chewers, this lightweight s-shaped tug toy is ideal for dogs whose bark is worse than their bite. It’ll help give your pup that much-needed release after a long day of lounging around and will satisfy even the most gentle chewers.

$20 at Amazon

Maxbone Decagon Rubber Toy

$14

Keeping your dog’s teeth clean has never been easier with this ultramodern tug toy. Maxbone is known for making pet products that fit the lifestyle of their humans, meaning nothing looks out of place or unsightly. This one is no different — it’s decagonal design makes it easy to play tug with. It also helps build jaw strength and relieves anxiety and boredom.

$14 at Maxbone

ChuckIt! Ultra Tug Dog Toy

Nothing is as classic as a good old fashioned tennis ball. A natural progression to create a fun, interactive experience for your dog is attaching a tugging device to the ball. This tug toy is perfect for moderate chewers and is easy to clean, which makes it a no-brainer.

$5 at Amazon

Goughnuts Durable Dog Pull Toy

$40

These durable circular toys are like donuts your dogs can sink their teeth into without incurring a nasty stomach ache. Ideal for aggressive chewers, these toys will stand the test of time and can endure the strength of dogs up to 120 pounds.

$40 at Amazon

Kong Durable Stretchy Rubber Tug Toy

$16

This stretchy durable tug toy makes for easy playtime between a doggy duo and encourages human-pup bonding. It has a comfortable grip that makes a game of tug-of-war safe and comfortable for both human and dog.

$16 at Amazon

Ruffwear Pacific Loop Dog Toy

$25

This wide-handled tug toy is constructed with both dogs and their parents in mind — designed as a reward for training, Ruffwear’s pacific loop toy is perfect for a game of fetch or working on cues, such as “drop it.” Plus, it’s waterproof and trail-tested, so you can rest assured your pup will be able to enjoy it for years to come.

$25 at Amazon

Btw, our editors (and their pets) picked out these products. They’re always in stock at the time we publish, but there’s a chance they’ll sell out. If you do buy through our links, we may earn a commission. (We’ve got a lot of toys to buy over here, you know?