Your Dog Might Actually Care When You Cry, Says Science

People who say that pets don’t understand human emotions clearly have never had their laps nuzzled or tears licked away during an ugly-cry session. They have a special way of picking us when we’re down, and their unconditional love can be a salve through life’s trying moments. 

If you’ve ever wondered what your pet is thinking as they comfort you when you cry, you’re not alone. The extent to which animals — primarily dogs — can understand and empathize with human sadness is the topic of some pretty fascinating ongoing research. So, grab the tissues — we’re exploring the latest on why and how dogs respond to tears. Spoiler alert (as if the headline didn’t give it away): they do — sometimes.

Related article

To Cry Is Human — and Apparently Canine

Time to whip out The Notebook for a little doggy movie night.

It’s not in your head: Dogs do seem to be attentive to crying.

“It’s pretty extensively established that dogs do respond to human crying,” Julia Manor, Ph.D., an animal cognition and neuroscience researcher and associate professor at Ripon College, tells us. “This has been found in audio recordings and live demonstrations with children and adults.” 

For example, in her own work, Manor has found that pet dogs are more likely to engage with whomever is pretending to cry in the room that they’re in — be it their guardian or a stranger. “When the stranger pretended to cry, rather than approaching their usual source of comfort, their owner, dogs sniffed, nuzzled and licked the stranger instead,” the 2012 study reads.

Separate research found that dogs’ cortisol levels increased after listening to a recording of an infant crying, suggesting some level of cross-species empathy. But interestingly enough, positive emotions don’t seem to be as contagious as sad ones. For another one of her studies, Manor and her team tested how pups reacted to human laughter. They found that laughing did not seem to impact dogs’ stress response or person-oriented behaviors (ie., eye contact, nuzzling, licking, barking) to the extent that crying did. 

“That tells us that there’s something unique about the crying emotion that may elicit responses,” she explains. 

So far we know, based on research that has tracked dog behavior as well as physiological metrics, like heart rate variability, that crying is stimulating to pups — even more so than other displays of human emotion. Still, the question remains: why? 

Related article

Is That... Stress Your Dog Smells? This Study Says So

Research finds that your pup can tell—er, smell—when you’ve been doom-scrolling.

There are some theories as to why dogs are so attentive to tears.

One explanation for why dogs respond to human crying is that their guardians have trained them to. If you (intentionally or not) reward your dog with treats and belly rubs after they nuzzle up with you during a sob fest, they’re more than likely to do it again next time.

However, there’s likely more to the story, because dogs don’t only respond to negative emotions when they come from people they know. Different breeds have shown the ability to match images of “sad” human faces to distressed human sounds — even when the face in question is a total stranger, and the sound is in another language than the one the dog hears at home. This means that part of their tendency to “catch” the emotions of people —also referred to as an emotional contagion — is innate. In fact, it could be centuries in the making. 

When you consider that dogs have shared more of their evolutionary history with humans than any other domestic animal, it makes sense that there’s a primitive element to their empathy.

Kun Guo, Ph.D., a human-animal interaction researcher at the University of Lincoln, says that the ability to read and respond to human emotions has likely served dogs well for eons. “You could argue that empathy is one of the most important functions for animals to survive because it promotes pro-social behavior and can build a link between your emotions and social functions,” he says of the evolutionary value of empathy. 

Related article

Chemistry Between People and Dogs Is Real (It’s Science)

How the “love hormone” oxytocin connects us with our pups.

If your dog doesn’t react when you cry, they still love you.

Fast forward to today, and Manor caveats that not every dog will engage with humans as they cry. In her research, she’s found that around 30 percent of pups “could care less” about tears.

“People will be crying, and the dogs are like, ‘Yeah, you need to deal with that yourself,’” she jokes. If you’re in this camp, it doesn’t mean your dog doesn’t love you. It could just be a reflection of their breed (Guo has an interesting theory that short-nose breeds might be more likely to respond to crying because their eyesight can be more attuned to nuances at close distances than longer-nose breeds) or their baseline anxiety level.

“Dogs who are a little more anxious tend to show more person-oriented behaviors to the person who is crying,” Manor has found. 

The impact of a dog’s breed and behavior are just a few aspects of animal empathy that researchers are still trying to wrap their heads around. In the future, Manor and Guo predict more studies will look into how dogs respond to other emotions like anger and other physical states of being like illness or injury. We could also see research on how other animals, such as cats, mice, and chickens, experience emotional contagion.

Until then, remember that the next time life has you reaching for the tissues, your dog could be right behind you — be it because of how you trained them or how they were born. Either way, their companionship is real, reassuring, and worthy of a runny-nosed smile.

Research: 

• Dogs Functionally Respond to and Use Emotional Information from Human Expressions

• Emotional Contagion: Dogs and Humans Show a Similar Physiological Response to Human Infant Crying

• Dogs Recognize Dog and Human Emotions

• Empathic-Like Responding by Domestic Dogs (Canis familiaris) to Distress in Humans: an Exploratory Study